Schools ditching Google Search is no longer a hypothetical debate in several major districts. New York City, Chicago and Los Angeles Unified are considering alternatives after Google said schools that disable its Gemini-powered features would also lose access to Google Search beginning next year, according to reporting by The Verge and The New York Times.
No district has announced that it has moved students off Google Search. The immediate issue is the choice Google has described: retain its AI features alongside Search, or turn off the AI features and lose Search access as well.
Los Angeles Unified officials had hoped students could continue using Google Search with AI features disabled, according to a New York Times excerpt. Chicago Public Schools told Google it would look at other search tools if the company could not offer Search without AI, The Verge reported.
New York City Schools Chancellor Kamar H. Samuels said the city would explore other search options if Google did not change course. The city's mayor, Zohran Mamdani, had recently announced a policy barring students in 2-K through eighth grade from using AI in the classroom, according to The Verge.
Why are schools considering Google Search alternatives?
The dispute is over product control, not an outage or a completed procurement. Districts that want to limit Gemini for students say they want the option to keep a conventional search service. Under the reported policy, opting out of Gemini-powered features would remove that option.
Google education vice president Chris Phillips told The New York Times that Search and AI are “deeply integrated.” He said schools that turn off Google's AI features would not have access to Search, according to The Verge's account of the interview.
That integration is the practical mechanism behind the conflict. Google is treating Search and its Gemini features as a combined service for schools rather than as separately selectable settings. The reporting does not include a policy document specifying which Gemini functions would apply, how districts would make the choice, or what alternative providers the districts might evaluate.
What has Google said about AI in Search for students?
Google spokesperson Laura Breen told The Verge that the company shared parents' and teachers' concerns that students could use AI to shortcut learning. She said Google was starting a pilot of Guided Learning capabilities in Search this month, designed to take students through complex problems step by step instead of supplying quick answers.
That is Google's stated educational rationale, not evidence of how the pilot will work in classrooms. For now, the record supports a narrower conclusion: New York City, Chicago and Los Angeles Unified are weighing their options, while Google is standing by a model that joins access to Search with its AI features.
This story draws on original reporting from The Verge.